Best Overall
Elgato 4K S
Key details
- HDR
- HDR10
- Audio Input
- 3.5mm analog
- Passthrough
- 1440p120 / 1080p240
- Capture Resolution
- 4K60
Recording 4K60 used to mean opening the desktop and giving up a PCIe slot. The Elgato 4K S does it from a USB-C box small enough to sit behind a laptop, and it handles 1440p120 or 1080p240 passthrough so a high-refresh monitor does not have to drop to 60Hz while you record. HDR10 capture is here too, with tone mapping on Windows.
What earns it the top spot is the balance of capability and portability. The 4K Pro is the more powerful internal card, but it needs a desktop and a PCIe slot; the 4K S moves between machines and takes a 3.5mm mic or chat feed without an extra mixer. We also appreciated the simple setup: it appeared as a source in OBS without a power brick or a pile of adapters.
The caveats are practical. The minimum system requirements are specific: Windows 11 64-bit or macOS 13 or later, an eighth-gen Intel Core i5 or Ryzen, and an M1-class Apple chip or better. An older laptop may not handle the 4K mode. Check the OS list before buying if you are on an older Mac or still running Windows 10.
For a streamer who wants 4K recordings and a high-refresh display in the same setup, the 4K S is the least fussy way to get both. It is also the card we prefer for a camera feed with commentary, because the analog input saves a separate audio interface. The 4K Pro remains the choice when the card can live inside a desktop; for everyone else, this is the one.
Pros
- Captures 4K60 with HDR10
- 1440p120 or 1080p240 passthrough
- 3.5mm analog audio input
- Compact USB-C design
Cons
- No HDMI cable included
The 4K S is our default for streamers who want 4K60 recordings without opening their PC, with high-refresh passthrough and a useful analog audio input.